Film Critic
Film Critic is a low-riding mayfly emerger with a trailing shuck and CDC wing that sits half-in, half-out of the surface film. It supports Film Critic fly, mayfly emerger, and selective trout searches.
Imitates: Emerging mayflies (BWO, PMD, sulphur, Callibaetis)
Quick Reference
- Best Sizes
- #16-22
- Best Season
- Spring through fall
- Best Conditions
- Slow flats, spring creeks, and selective rise pools
- Water Temp
- 48-66°F
- Recommended Tippet
- 5X-6X
How to Rig It
Fish solo or as the trailer 14 inches behind a parachute dun.
How to Present It
Drag-free drift with the fly riding low in the film.
Why It Works
The trailing shuck and flush body match a mayfly mid-emergence — exactly when trout target them most.
History
Modern emerger evolution combining shuck + low CDC wing for technical hatches.
Pro Tip
Treat only the wing with floatant so the body stays stuck in the film.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should I fish a Film Critic?+
During any mayfly hatch when trout refuse upright duns.
Not sure if Film Critic is right today?
Get a fly recommendation based on live water temp, flow, sky, and time of day for any river in the US.
Open Fly Advisor
Map
Fly Guide